(I write this as an Indian Australian who has been calling Australia home for more than 20 years, and as someone who travels around the world regularly. And I am greatly concerned about the potential loss of trust and international reputation of a great country).
Over the past few days in Melbourne (and also in India) a hot issue has come up – is Australia a racist country? Tuesday morning over 1000 Indian students were protesting by blocking traffic in the heart of Melbourne city, with 18 subsequent arrests. It has truly become an international issue. Due to the hype and speculation, a well known Indian movie star – Amitabh Bachchan – has rejected an honorary doctorate awarded to him by the Queensland University of Technology. He said, “Under the prevailing circumstances I find it inappropriate at this juncture to accept this decoration. My conscience does not permit me to accept this decoration from a country that perpetrates such indignity to my fellow countrymen.â€Â
The stabbing with a screwdriver of an Indian student has become a hot political and social issue at the highest level, where the two countries prime ministers, ambassadors and every other group that you can imagine has got involved. And here is my two dollars worth – or should that be two rupees worth?!
I have been living in Australia for more than 20 years and have many Indian friends; I have never experienced any situation that could be labeled as racism. I have many friends who are Indian and of other nationalities who all love Australia and see it as a privilege to be living in this country. That is not to say all Australians are perfect – far from it. Australians are just as much sinners, selfish and nationalistic as anyone else in a civilized society.Â
In fact, the only time I have felt racially discriminated against was while I was in New Delhi, India! I was taking a taxi but because I did not speak Hindi (being south Indian my mother tongue is Malayalam) the taxi driver got angry with me and scolded me – in English – saying, “If you don’t speak Hindi you don’t deserve to be driven by me!â€
In one sense we are all racist, including myself – I might think that my food and way of thinking and doing is better than others. So in this and any other similar situation let us remember the words of Jesus: “He who has no sin cast the first stone… first take the log out of your own eye and then take the speck out of others’ eyes.â€
So before getting excited by what you see, hear and read in the media and start pointing fingers at others and making allegations and accusations against the general public, it is better that we take time to review, assess and evaluate ourselves.
Now, I am not saying that there is no issue with Indian students in Australia. In fact, the statistics and circumstances tend to prove that there are major issues (it is reported that there is been more than 500 attacks on Indian students over the past 4 years). But is it racially motivated or could it be because of other issues? I don’t believe that it is racially motivated; if it was, the whole of the Indian community would become a target but very clearly that is not the case.
I don’t believe that these are racially motivated attacks rather opportunistic because of following reasons:
Most Indian students come to Australia through various agencies, who are interested in making money; they get the visa and get the students in the country. Generally speaking, once they are in the country they have no responsibility. The students are largely left to find their own way in a very different culture.
-Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â So they end up living in areas where they are vulnerable and often exposed to the worst groups of people in the society.
-         They also look for part-time jobs. Again, because either they are desperate or because they are not educated about the risk of certain jobs, they end up doing some of the more “risky†jobs like driving taxis or doing nights working at petrol service stations.
-Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Most of them work late and rely on public transport and walking to get home. Again, because they are not educated or aware of the nasty elements of the city they walk right into these areas and become victims.
-         Most of the students also come from a very close family and community culture. So when they are in a new city they are desperate to find a “family and communityâ€. This also could lure them into the wrong crowd if they are not careful.
-         Indian culture is a very hospitable culture; they talk to anyone and everyone. If you have traveled on Indian trains or buses you will know what I mean. So when they are here, they will do the same, smiling, joking and talking with or about strangers is very normal but could have a very different result in this culture. Inviting a stranger into your home or giving your personal details in India is quite normal but may not be wise in this culture.
This list can go on and on but what I believe is that all of these factors could be putting the Indian students in the wrong place, at the wrong time with the wrong group of people. With more than 80,000 students studying across Australia, and more and more Indian students going overseas to study, we will likely continue to see such incidents.
To get rid of these kinds of things in the future I believe the following steps should be considered:
1.      The agents who bring the students should be held responsible in helping, managing and educating the students into the new country, culture and society and not be allowed to end their responsibility once they have their payment.
2.      The Government and universities who are financially profiting from these students need to ensure they are providing relevant cultural education, get the police to teach about the nasty elements of our cities etc.
3.      There should be a national hotline and a centre where these and students from other countries can call for help, report incidents and dob in dodgy agents, land lords etc. Many foreign students will be afraid to go to the police (or other authorities) because of their own understanding of the police role in society.
Is Australia a racist country? There is no doubt about Australia’s racist past but I know that each of us (individually and as counties) have our pasts and some skeletons in our closets. Are Australians today the same as in the past? The simple answer is, if you consider yourself to be racist then Australia also could be! Even if there is a small group of people who are racist we need to be very careful in not slamming the vast majority of good natured, generous and kind-hearted Australians who love to support the underdog and believe in a fair go for everyone!
Let us all pray for wisdom, common sense and justice – and a good, quick resolution.
Blessings – jossy chasko
Recent Comments